Amazing Journey
 
 
  Sweeney Todd
Rolling Stone
Issue 988
by Peter Travers
 
 

Stephen Sondheim’s indisputably magnificent “Sweeney Todd” is the greatest
musical of the 20th century. Now, in this dark and dazzling reinvention by British
director John Doyle, "Sweeney" stakes its claim as the gold standard for the next
hundred years as well. The sweep that Hal Prince delivered in his original 1979
production has been replaced by Doyle’s claustrophobic, monster-in-a-box staging.
The setting is a madhouse where the inmates have taken over the job of telling the
story of “The Demon Barber of Fleet Street.” It’s some story.

As played by a fierce Michael Cerveris, Sweeney is a 19th-century symbol of vengeance. Back in London
after escaping a prison where he’d been sent by the evil judge who raped his wife and
kidnapped his daughter, the barber means to slit the judge’s throat. Foiled at first, he
decides to vent his rage by killing all of his customers. As he sings, “we all deserve to
die.” His accomplice is Mrs. Lovett—Patti Lupone in a performance of vocal artistry,
comic subtlety and scary brilliance. Tired of killing pussycats to stuff in the meat pies
she sells in her shop, Mrs. Lovett persuades the barber to let her use the bodies of his
victims. As Sondheim’s lyric bluntly puts it: “It’s man devouring man my dear/and
who are we to deny it in here?”

The original production played the story for social satire. Doyle internalizes the
conflict and brings it up close and personal. In his riskiest move, Doyle has the ten
principle actors double as musicians. The show’s young lovers (Benjamin Magnuson
and Lauren Molina, both excellent) also play cellos. It works like a charm. The cast is
flawless with Alexander Gemignani superb as the judge’s cohort and Manoel
Felciano—possessed of an angel’s voice— heartbreaking as a boy caught up in this
city on fire.

Demons are prowling in this riveting rethinking of a masterwork. And don’t buy the
Sondheim ballad about how “nothing’s gonna harm you.” Everything is.
 
 
  back to articles  
  back to main  




Amazing Journey - Official Web Archive for Michael Cerveris
Please send any comments about this page and contributions
to email - webmaster@michaelcerveris.com